My favorite mistakes: The sentences I look for in a manuscript

There’s a certain type of sentence I love finding in a draft of a manuscript. It’s not a sentence that is particularly beautiful or insightful. Quite the opposite, in fact. It’s a sentence that hints at something the author has yet to fully excavate, like an artifact partially sticking out of the dirt or a door to a room you just discovered. These sentences suggest ideas or arguments that the author is approaching but hasn’t yet fully pursued. The places where, if we’re being honest, maybe they got a little tired when they were writing and just didn’t have the energy to think anymore. These are the places that point to where the manuscript can grow in complexity, precision, and narrative coherence. They are, most importantly, opportunities for analysis. And all writers, whether they are writing fantasy novels or scholarly research, should care deeply about analysis.

Let’s look at an example from a high-profile biography of a historical figure. This book was published by a big-5 publisher and reviewed by an A-list academic in the New York Times. I’ve anonymized the text below to protect the well-meaning historian who, no doubt, spent years on this project. They are probably a lovely person who tips well and writes nurturing, thoughtful feedback on their students’ papers. And yet! This book is a case study in missed writing opportunities: narrative threads are introduced and then abandoned; documentary evidence is cherry-picked and often left to explain itself without further analysis, potentially provocative and illuminating claims are criminally underdeveloped. See if you can identify the gaps in this paragraph:

“X left few memories about his early life, and he wrote nothing about his parents. Diligence and ambition—achieving well beyond one’s age or assumed capacity—nevertheless marked his youth. In his later writings to his children, he voiced an insistence on their hard work in their every pursuit. His determination gives us some clue about his early life. There was no time to waste. His desire to prove himself at an early age reveals something essential about his young years.”

Do you see those words I bolded just for you? Those imprecise nouns that ask us to look at something hazy and undefined on the horizon? This something essential points to a gap in the narrative, an under-developed idea that could, if pursued, made a well-developed and illuminating claim about the subject that clearly connects his early life to the uniquely tragic events for which he is famed as an adult.

Let me repeat: I love finding a sentence like this in a manuscript. I’ll say, “do you see how this sentence raises a question for the reader? What is the something essential?” This question pushes the analysis further by forcing the author to explicitly articulate an interpretation of how the subject’s early life shaped his character.

This paragraph, and specifically the phrase something essential point us toward a key insight about writing: Good writing is specific. Analysis, my friends, is specific, and it dies in broad, vague, or imprecise language. It is borne out of a curiosity about one’s subject that causes one to doggedly interrogate details, to look tirelessly for patterns, to be dissatisfied with shallow or general conclusions that do not begin to approach the layers of bedrock out of which a subject emerges. It stands to reason then that imprecise, placeholder nouns like something, idea, things, and so forth, are the enemy of analysis and of the kind of writing that excavates the humanity of your subject down to its clean, sun-bleached bones. This sort of precision is not just an accumulation of unrelated detail. It is the precision that weaves these seemingly unrelated details into a sturdy rope of narrative that brings our subject to life through a well-paced, cohesive, and intriguing story.

If I was editing this book, I would recommend the following steps for revising this paragraph and the chapter that follows:

1. State your answer to this question: what is the something essential that this tendency reveals about the subject’s childhood?

2. Structure the rest of the subsection as a demonstration of that claim.

3. Carefully select the evidence that best illustrates that claim, while noting the limitations of that evidence and the gaps that still remain.

As a reader, I love encountering a well-managed plot that skillfully arranges and analyzes evidence in service of the overall story (and yes - scholarly writing is storytelling). As an editor, I love working with writers to bring that story into focus by brushing the dust off the details so that the whole emerges more clearly.

Next
Next

Bridging the gap between editing and teaching